Modified and Context-Focused Sports Intervention in Adolescents With Autism: Study Protocol

Adolescents exhibit higher levels of sedentary behavior compared to other age groups. This situation is even more evident among adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), who show significantly lower levels of physical activity than typically developing adolescents. Studies have revealed that most adolescents with ASD did not meet the three components of the Canadian 24-Hour Movement Guidelines, which include physical activity, sedentary time, and sleep. Low levels of physical activity may contribute to high rates of physical or mental health problems among young people with ASD, including a higher prevalence of overweight and obesity. Intrinsic factors, such as mobility limitations and difficulties with social interaction, may restrict the participation of children and adolescents with ASD in physical activities. Despite these challenges, evidence suggests that including these young people in physical activity programs can yield significant benefits, such as increased peer social interaction and improvements in motor and communication skills. However, participation in physical activities tends to decline with age, resulting in less engagement from adolescents with ASD compared to younger children with the same diagnosis. Therefore, it is crucial to develop effective strategies to promote the participation of these individuals in physical activities. Several interventions aim to promote the participation of children and adolescents with ASD in physical activities, including modified sports programs. These programs are defined as recreational activities where rules, equipment, or spaces are modified to enhance sports inclusion and develop fundamental motor skills. Despite the recognition of the importance of modified sports for children's preparation for sports and physical activity, there is still a lack of such interventions for individuals with disabilities, especially in low- and middle-income countries. To address this gap, the Sports Stars program was developed in Australia. This intervention involves modified sports activities led by professionals and delivered in peer groups. Sports Stars focuses on supporting the development of intrinsic factors, such as physical, social, cognitive, and psychological competence in children, or their physical literacy. The program was adapted to the Brazilian context to promote the participation of children and adolescents with cerebral palsy and ASD in physical activities. A quasi-experimental study assessed the acceptability and initial outcomes of this modified sports intervention for Brazilian adolescents with ASD. Sports Stars proved to be feasible, and the preliminary results were positive for promoting participation and improving gross motor skills (such as locomotion and object control), physical conditioning, and physical literacy (social, psychological, cognitive, and physical) in these individuals. However, no planned clinical trials have yet been conducted specifically for this population. Although adolescents improved their participation in the Sports Stars program, these individuals and their families still report barriers to participation in sports and community recreational activities. Modified sports interventions promote participation in physical activities in individuals with ASD by addressing intrinsic factors; however, they do not address contextual barriers, such as environmental and interpersonal factors, which also influence participation. Factors such as bullying, parents' perceptions often prioritizing therapeutic intervention, and challenges faced in community programs (such as the lack of adaptations in existing programs to meet their needs) are still prevalent. some of these obstacles, which reduce adherence to physical activities. Therefore, it may be necessary to combine interventions targeting intrinsic factors, such as Sports Stars, with those that address the extrinsic contextual factors impacting the participation of adolescents with ASD in their community. An example of an intervention focused on context is the Pathways and Resources for Engagement and Participation (PREP). PREP is an approach designed for clinicians seeking to increase participation by modifying extrinsic factors or barriers embedded in someone's environment. Examples include physical, social, attitudinal, institutional, and contextual barriers. The main goal is to guide and empower youth and families to solve problems by navigating barriers, sharing the necessary information to help them achieve their desired participation goals. In this approach, the therapist collaborates with the individual and their caregivers to identify facilitators and barriers to participation and create strategies to minimize or remove potential obstacles. A context-based practice study conducted with children with ASD demonstrated that this intervention can promote increased participation in self-chosen activities over time. Furthermore, a feasibility clinical trial showed that the combination of the Sports Stars Brazil and PREP interventions for children with cerebral palsy provided preliminary evidence that this combination led to greater achievement of participation goals and family empowerment compared to Sports Stars alone. The complementary approach of combining intrinsic interventions (Sports Stars) and extrinsic interventions (PREP) aligns with the relationships between the person, their environment, and the quantity and quality of their participation, as proposed in the "family of constructs related to participation." By recognizing that participation depends on both the individual's skills and the contexts and conditions in which it occurs, professionals can adopt a more holistic and personalized approach to individual needs. Therefore, the objective of this mixed-methods study protocol is to assess the effectiveness of the combined Sports Stars Brazil and PREP intervention for adolescents with ASD in improving participation outcomes (frequency and engagement) and physical literacy (physical, social, cognitive, and psychological competence), as well as to analyze self-perceived performance and satisfaction with the selected physical activity, and the perceptions and experiences of adolescents and their families regarding this combined intervention through qualitative focus groups and photovoice. Hypotheses: * Adolescents with ASD who receive the combined Sports Stars Brazil and PREP intervention will demonstrate greater participation in physical activities, and their caregivers will report higher levels of family empowerment, compared to those who receive only Sports Stars Brazil. * Adolescents who receive the combined Sports Stars Brazil and PREP intervention will exhibit higher levels of physical literacy compared to those who receive only Sports Stars Brazil. Design This study will be conducted using a mixed-methods approach, combining a randomized clinical trial and two qualitative studies. A central element of the research will be triangulation, which involves applying different analytical techniques to the same data set to assess the validity of the results. This method allows the integration of multiple sources of information, enhancing the comprehensiveness of the findings. the reliability and robustness of the findings. Consequently, the research incorporates multiple angles of analysis and varied perspectives, ensuring comprehensive results that are not confined to a single approach. This three-phase study is developed according to the SPIRIT guidelines, which provide guidance for the conduct of clinical trials. Future dissemination of results will be conducted in phase 1 according to the criteria for presenting pilot studies, following the CONSORT guidelines, and in phases 2 and 3 according to the COREQ criteria. The study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee (approval number 84826024.6.0000.5149) and will be registered in Clinical Trials under number XXXX. Methods Study Design A mixed-methods study consisting of three distinct phases: * Phase 1: Investigation of the effects of Sports Stars Brazil + PREP compared to Sports Stars alone through a randomized clinical trial (RCT). * Phase 2: Exploration of caregivers' perceptions regarding their children's experiences using semi-structured focus groups. * Phase 3: Exploration of adolescents' perceptions and experiences using the photovoice method. PPI (Public and Patient Involvement) Until the last decade, there were a limited number of studies actively involving individuals with ASD and their families. However, due to the advocacy efforts of patients, families, and activists, as well as the new policy of the journal Autism, which since January 2021 requires authors to report whether individuals with ASD were involved in their work, this number has increased, leading to up to five times more involvement of these individuals in research. In this approach, public and patient involvement (PPI) occurs "with" or "by" them, rather than being done "for," "about," or "to" them. Researchers, professionals, and the public (patients, caregivers, and representatives of organizations supporting these individuals) will collaborate fully, sharing responsibilities throughout the project, including in the creation of knowledge. To support this collaboration, the Engagement Matrix (EM) tool will be used. Developed to promote patient involvement in research for those aged 12 and older, the EM is structured with its center focusing on the roles that young people or the public can take on, defined in five distinct roles, and on the practical phases of the project. With the EM as a reference, the principal investigator will be responsible for managing the interactions with the adolescents.Additionally, the tool will enhance collaboration, streamline processes, and allow for more systematic reporting of cooperation. Two caregivers and two adolescents diagnosed with ASD who have previously participated in Sports Stars Brazil will be invited to join the research team as members. Their participation will be crucial in bringing valuable perspectives and personal experiences that will enrich the development of the project. The most important aspect to consider is that PPI facilitates communication with individuals who have relevant life experiences related to health issues, ensuring that their valuable voices and insights are incorporated/included. Intervention Phase I: Investigation of the Effects of Sports Stars Brazil + PREP Sports Stars Brazil Group (8 weeks) The intervention will be conducted with groups of 6 to 8 adolescents, lasting 1 hour per day, once a week, for 8 weeks, totaling 8 hours. Each group will be led by a physiotherapist, with the assistance of students and/or professionals in occupational therapy and physical education. Each participant will receive guidance from 1-2 direct and consistent professionals throughout the study. The sessions will be structured in the following order: gross motor skill training (jumping, running, motor control activities using a ball), followed by the introduction of popular sports in Brazil: soccer, handball, basketball, and athletics. Throughout the intervention period, the adolescents will be under the care of pre-trained interventionists. Given that children and adolescents with ASD may exhibit repetitive and stereotypical behaviors, support strategies will be implemented, such as providing verbal feedback, using visual cues, communicating rest times, hydration periods, and activity durations. Sports Stars + PREP Group (8 weeks) In addition to the Sports Stars program, adolescents randomized to the PREP group will simultaneously receive a context-focused intervention. This intervention aims to identify and remove potential barriers that hinder the participation of adolescents with ASD in sports, as well as recognize facilitators and develop strategies to overcome modifiable barriers. Both interventions will be conducted together by a physiotherapist and a pre-trained occupational therapist. The adolescents will receive personalized support to transition to their preferred physical activity in the community. This support will consist of eight weekly meetings, each approximately one hour long, with a team composed of physiotherapists and occupational therapists. This intervention will be based on the PREP methodology, which includes five steps: (1) Setting goals, (2) Mapping a plan, (3) Making it happen, (4) Measuring the process and outcomes, and (5) Moving forward. During this intervention, the therapists, along with the participant and their family/adolescent, will: 1) identify barriers to participating in their preferred physical activities, 2) propose a modification plan, 3) implement modifications to facilitate sports participation, and 4) assess the outcomes of the modifications. This intervention will be conducted individually for each participant, together with their family. The specific type of context-focused intervention and the amount carried out will be recorded by the therapists individually for each participant. Phase II: Evaluation of Caregivers' Experiences Regarding the Sports Stars Intervention Study Design and Objectives In this phase, a qualitative study will be conducted with the aim of exploring the experiences of family members of adolescents with ASD who participated in the Sports Stars program. Procedures and Data Collection Data collection for Phase II will occur as follows: After participation in the Sports Stars Brazil + PREP intervention, focus groups will be held with one family member of each participant at the School of Physical Education, Physiotherapy, and Occupational Therapy of UFMG. Data will be collected in each focus group only once and in person, with an expected duration of 1 hour per interview, extendable if necessary. To ensure homogeneity in data collection, the interviewers responsible will undergo prior training. Sample characterization data, which are considered important for this study, will be collected before the focus groups and will include: age, gender, communication level classification (for adolescents), socioeconomic status, and parents' education level. During the interview, only the adolescents and interviewers will be present. Semi-structured questions will be asked, focusing on the Family Participation Constructs, which provide the theoretical framework for the Sports Stars and PREP interventions. Additionally, parents will be asked about their experiences participating in the combined Sports Stars Brazil and PREP program. During the focus groups, the interviewers will present an explanatory video on the "Family of Participation Constructs" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLzQW2R9XAM), produced by the researchers. This video will highlight the key aspects of the Participation domain of the International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health (ICF) in a familiar language, to help clarify the discussion on experiences in the combined Sports Stars Brazil + PREP program. The focus groups with parents will be conducted immediately after the intervention and will be recorded for later transcription and data analysis. The audio of the focus groups will be recorded for later transcription. After this process, the interviewee will have access to the transcription to verify the data and information before content analysis by the researchers. Additionally, during the focus groups and facilitation, if deemed necessary by the evaluator, notes will be taken. For qualitative data analysis, the MAXQDA software will be used. Phase III: Evaluation of Adolescents' Experiences Regarding the Sports Stars Intervention Through Photovoice Study Design and Objectives In this phase, a qualitative study will be conducted using the Photovoice method, with the aim of exploring the experiences of adolescents with ASD who participated in the Sports Stars program. Photovoice is a useful tool for adopting a participant-centered strategy, focusing on participation and individual perceptions. Procedures and Data Collection Data collection for Phase III will occur as follows: The third initial phase of the study will be structured in six distinct stages and will begin in the fourth week of the intervention. Photography Training: Adolescents, accompanied by a responsible adult, will receive basic training in photographic techniques and camera (or smartphone) use. This training will also address ethics and consent. To ensure homogeneity in data collection, the interviewers will undergo prior training. Image Collection: The adolescents will be instructed, through guided questions, to capture 18 photos representing their participation, with 3 photos for each question. The activity will take place over 45 days, allowing the adolescents to reflect on their involvement in various aspects of daily life. Reflection on the Images: After the photo collection, the adolescents will meet with a trained evaluator for an interview to reflect on their images. Each photo will be discussed, and the adolescents will describe their narratives or captions, explaining the meaning behind their choices. Transcription and Categorization: The focus groups will be transcribed and categorized to facilitate data analysis. Validation of Results: The results will be discussed and validated with caregivers. Presentation of Results: The findings will be presented to professionals, families, and the community, promoting the exchange of experiences and learnings. This process aims not only to document the adolescents' experiences but also to encourage deep reflection on their lives and foster enriching dialogue. A study demonstrated that Photovoice is highly valued by adolescents aged 15 to 17 who use mental health services. This approach promotes personal reflection, the identification of strengths, and the increase of empowerment, which is the main goal of Photovoice.